A CHANGE WILL DO YOU GOOD

by Holly Horning

If you’re a Tiger fan, then you’re familiar with all the stories about players who did not do well in Detroit and then performed much better when they moved to other teams.

Now there’s proof that there was substance to those tales.

Several young players have discussed their early development with Detroit as a factor in their struggles to progress in the system.

There is Spencer Torkelson who was rushed up to Detroit last year out of desperation to validate the rebuild.  He did not do well, even after returning from a refresher in Toledo.

You may remember that Tork was drafted by the Tigers as a third baseman, despite never having played that position.  That move raised eyebrows within most MLB Front Offices.

The Tigers then actually put him at 3B so he could learn the position.  It did not go well and he was moved back to first base.

But when you make significant changes, it sacrifices some of the focus needed in a player’s development and progress.

Spencer had to make positional changes and work on his offense at the same time.  And the Tigers gave him only 1 year in which to master it all.

That’s a rather tall order.

But then they also tried to change his swing.  This was all before the Player Development department was overhauled and before Ryan Garko was hired.

We know how well that worked out.

Since last year, Torkelson has been adamant about returning to the swing he used in college.  Many of us thought he was just being young and stubborn.

It is now appearing that maybe he was right.

After working with the new hitting coaches over the winter, we’re hearing that his swing potentially may be returning to what got him to the majors. Albeit with potentially a few minor tweaks after Dr. Lund does a full analysis of how his body moves most efficiently.

Earlier this week, I blogged about the changes to Eric Haase’s set-up behind the plate that is also being tweaked in order to allow him to become a better defensive player.  He’s been with the Tigers for 3 years but no one, until now, has been able to diagnose the issues because the team didn’t have the right equipment or specialists who could figure it out.

And now there’s Alex Faedo.

Faedo recently gave an interview where he talked about how the Tigers, when he was signed, changed his pitching mechanics.

Then he revealed that the change is what created his hip injury that required surgery last year.  He has now gone back to his former delivery style on the advice of the new specialists.

Alex credits all the new people for getting him back on track.  He gave a shout out to Director of Pitching, Gabe Ribas, pitching rehab coordinator, John DeRouin, rehab specialists Corey Tremble and Duncan Evans and strength coaches Francisco Rivas and Ryan Maedel.

What do these 3 players have in common?

They were getting old, outdated advice from an organization that lacked the tools and skills to guide and develop the best performance from its talent.

Until this year.

The Tigers now have added to their technology which allows them to break down a player’s movement into milli-seconds and then feed the info into super computers.  They also have new coaches like Dr. Robin Lund who can then take this info and apply their expertise in kinesiology to ensure that any movement performed will not create injury.

Not having these resources could also be a factor in the number of other pitchers who have ended up on the IL going back quite a few years.  How many of them had (now) former coaches change how they pitched?

It’s the same process that they are undoubtedly using to assess Spencer Torkelson’s swing mechanics and also Eric Haase’s positioning behind the plate that will improve his pitch framing and lessen the number of balls in the dirt.

It would appear that the Tigers have finally moved into the 21st Century and successfully embraced technology while hiring specialists.

It also looks like they finally have people who are capable of accurately interpreting the data and advice.

It’s being reported that while Al Avila brought analytics to the Tigers, he did not create a system in which data was correctly interpreted, nor did he create a system in which the information was communicated efficiently throughout the organization.  Their analytics department, along with their infrastructure and technology, was considered to be outdated within MLB even when it was new.

The rest of MLB savaged the Tigers for their antiquated approach.  Ken Rosenthal reported that a number of other GMs questioned “whether Avila (was) creative and savvy enough to build a consistent winner” and stated about Detroit “Not like they had a lot of cutting-edge ideas.”

Enter Avila’s polar opposite, Scott Harris, who is considered to be creative and forward-thinking.  He has now brought the Tigers into modern times.

You won’t read much about it.  It’s not sexy or exciting.  And the eyes of readers will roll into the backs of their heads if they have to read in-depth descriptions of how the technology works.  But much has been done to overhaul and modernize the team’s infrastructure, personnel and technology. 

Harris has gotten Chris Ilitch to invest tens of millions in the newest systems, video and computers.  Not to mention the hiring of a significant number of specialists and coaches to advise talent especially in the areas of biomechanics and kinesiology.

All of this is contained in 1 of Harris’ 3 tenets:  the culture of development.  That top priority was singled out by Scott because he didn’t see it existing in the Tigers’ organization.

He said: “An area of focus for us is helping players get better.  We’re introducing a lot of new things to the players that they’ve never seen before. And with that comes huge opportunity to help them get better, to find those small gains up and down the roster that can net huge returns for the team. That’s going to be our path back to contention and I feel we are off to a good start.”

So why are we just reading about the poor advice given to players in the past like Faedo, Haase and Torkelson?

Because the previous regime didn’t know what they didn’t know.

There’s now a new coaching staff, brand new training, conditioning and medical groups and a new technology system that is creating new and better data.  Updated development concepts are being taught and new training tools are being used.  And this blogger is overjoyed to finally read that players are taking yoga and pilates classes to address the repeated core injuries that were ignored under the former regime. 

It’s about time.

Bu all of this won’t create an immediate fix.  We won’t see instant results.  It will be a gradual process.  Like all things in life, players need to buy in, adjust and get comfortable with all the new information being thrown at them now.

So far, it’s promising.  Harris stated:  “They’ve responded to it very well.  But there is an adjustment period and it takes time for these new concepts to gain traction and produce results.”

Fans as well will need an adjustment period. 

This was an outdated organization for decades that previous owners ignored.  One covered up the problem by throwing vast amounts of money at the roster by buying talent from other teams.  But that only masked the problems.  It was a superficial fix.

What’s going on now within the office walls of Comerica isn’t as exciting.  But it’s much more promising.  And it’s finally digging down to the root of the problem.

And hopefully, we’ll start to see positive results trickling up to the surface. Soon. Hopefully very soon.

Don’t see your comment? Comments are limited to a maximum of 3 sentences. Please make sure to check out the other rules for posting under the link at the top of the page in order for your comments to be published.


What did you miss on our Twitter feed yesterday?

  • The stats of one Tiger will astound you. How many times did he miss out getting on base simply because he couldn’t control the strike zone?

Why should you follow Totally Tigers https://twitter.com/totallytigersbb on Twitter?

  • We tweet out breaking news before it’s published in the sports pages. The best news from the best sources.
  • Want more than 1 Totally Tigers fix every day? How about throughout the day?

34 thoughts on “A CHANGE WILL DO YOU GOOD

  1. Holly, I’m assuming you’re watching Spring training as it unfolds. Today you mentioned all the updates and the new people hired who work behind the scenes like Dr Lund. You also mentioned last fall how the old medical and training staff were sent packing specifically Doug Teeter sent to Lakeland. I’m curious if you have seen these individuals from the past.

    Liked by 4 people

  2. Patience for all of us is a virtue. Yes, we want a winner but this article illustrates how far away we really were. Remember at this time last year the regime thought they had a playoff caliber year!

    Liked by 6 people

  3. Holly, a very interesting nugget there in that pitching coach and kinesiologist Dr. Robin Lund worked with Torkelson on his batting. I am glad to read that.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi, Brooks – I have no definitive proof that Lund has worked with him but Tork is a top priority for the team so one can assume they have met. The pitching coaches worked with him over the winter so I would think that they went in armed with suggestions for what to address. – Holly

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Poor Alex Faedo. Mathew Boyd had to attempt his own analytics with the old regime which is almost as jarring. In addition to making physical improvements in player performance the new development culture should also build confidence the many Tigers who have something to prove this year.

    Liked by 5 people

  5. Thanks for this Holly! Have more hope now. No more 66-96 now. I am not expecting contention for a playoff but some more competitive baseball. They may surprise us.

    Liked by 3 people

  6. Great reporting, Holly, on the changes being made under Harris – especially the details concerning specific players. Someone should send you to report on spring training as a reward. And if Al’s idea of a “modernization” was to build an analytics department using outdated infrastructure and technology, I bet his kitchen at home has avocado appliances and his car an 8-track tape player. 😉

    Liked by 8 people

    • I love your analogies. We know the old regime only got a toe into modern baseball. It will be interesting to see how Harris get the system to cohere and what he will do when inevitably not all goes according to plan.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. The statement that really struck me was “because the previous regime didn’t know what they didn’t know.” They just continued to fill Al’s cronnie corral with more incapable and pink shirt stubborn bulls. I think it’s awesome that Scott has assembled such a capable testing ground to evaluate those on the 40 man and the ST invites and the games start Saturday.

    Liked by 4 people

    • One thing I like about the Harris approach is that it anticipates the plethora of injuries that modern teams seem to encounter (particularly among pitchers). The beat writers were laughably quick to point out that the Avila teams has “bad luck” when the regulars hit the IL. Building quality organizational depth is an absolute requirement to competing these days.

      Liked by 3 people

  8. I bid the Detroit Tigers MLB franchise good luck in their efforts to revamp and remake the ballclub into a consistently competitive and perhaps an eventual cutting-edge, contending organization….for however longer that may take. But in the meantime, it appears that another big cat has grabbed most Detroit sportsfans attention and excitement recently, and is the one who is coaching-fielding exciting teams and players.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Friendly competition among a city’s professional franchises is good I think. It might be kind of like the friendly competition within a pitching staff that often helps everyone perform.

      Like

    • Detroit/Michigan used to be really into baseball. Brandon, as you imply, college and Pro football dominate the “headlines” as they have become year round. This is one reason that I find the Tigers’ meek marketing efforts so puzzling.

      Liked by 1 person

  9. Refreshing to see younger players get the tools they need to succeed. Every time I read about these significant improvements, I shake my head because Avila was more interested in his own comfort by leaving the same ineffective people employed.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. It will be really interesting to compare the Tigers’ success to the Twins over the next year or more. Detroit’s new approach is to achieve dozens of incremental changes while Minnesota has definitely gone for some big splashes with free agent signings and trades. I think the Twins will win out in attendance, but how will we look at their comparative rosters at year’s end?

    Liked by 2 people

    • The Texas Rangers are another team with a different approach that I plan to compare with the Tigers over the next few years. Even though the Rangers acquired top FAs Seager, Semien, deGrom, I still have a feeling the Tigers’ approach will be more successful. We will see.

      Liked by 3 people

      • I brought up the Twins because they are in our division, slightly smaller market and have sound management. They went all-in on Correa as we did not, took a flyer on Gallo and made aggressive trades. Texas is pretty reckless and random with their spending, but I am glad you brought them up because Harris needs to be compared in a broader context than merely Al Avila.

        Liked by 2 people

  11. Perhaps Haase’s lack of defensive capability behind the plate could be attributed to “defensive versatility”. Instead of giving him the time he deserved behind the plate, he was put in LF in a crowded outfield. Regarding Torkelson’s attempted move to 3B, many outside of the organization commented that not since Adrian Gonzalez was drafted first overall in 2000, was a “low grade” position such as first basemen drafted first overall.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi, Pondo – There were a number of top 5 picks who were drafted as 1Bers including Eric Hosmer, Brendan McKay and Andrew Vaughn. In Tork’s case, what made it esp. unusual is that he had never played 3B in his entire secondary or collegiate careers. Does a team draft a player is a sure bet and then gamble with his future and the team’s by putting him somewhere else (esp. a hard position like the hot corner) when there is zero experience? There was much written about how the Tigers set back Tork’s development by doing that at the time. – Holly

      Liked by 1 person

      • Given current circumstances one can see why the Tigers would hope he would adapt to 3B as it is easier to fill 1B. AJ is moving tons of players all over the diamond so this attempt does not seem out of line with his philosophy. Sands was moved to catcher as a kid, so I am not going fault the Avila regime on this.

        Liked by 1 person

        • I am not sure Hinch had much if anything to do with Torkelson being drafted as a 1st baseman and then told he would be moved to 3rd. Look at how Al Avila and company jerked Nick Castellanos around from position to position until finally Nick said no to a move to first base. I think the Tork move was history repeating itself.

          Liked by 1 person

          • Hi, Tigerway – Yes, you are correct. Hinch had nothing to do with the strategy for Tork. Spencer was drafted a year before Hinch was hired. The manager doesn’t create strategy for the minors but the GM, draft team and Player Development does. All of them are now gone.

            Liked by 2 people

  12. Old retired coach said a secret to successful coaching, and winning, is for your defensive coach being two plays ahead and knowing what his opponent was going to do before the opponent did. Pitching coach teaching a hitter to think like a pitcher. My kind of common sense. The coach was John Maddon.

    Liked by 3 people

  13. “Their(Tigers) analytics department, along with their infrastructure and technology, was considered to be outdated within MLB even when it was new.” That observation begs the question of whether or not Jay Sartori and his department eventually produced good and useful data or how many, if any, new personnel had to be added to make it an effective department. Jay Sartori is still on staff if that means anything.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi, Tigerway – You read my mind. Satori is an Avila hire which doesn’t bode well. Scott Harris can broom only so many people at once so I’m not surprise that Satori has stayed – for now. I believe he will be monitored and tested this year to see if he can adapt. But I also expect that Harris will be further editing his Front Office after this year. – Holly

      Liked by 2 people

  14. I see where this is hopefully going, and it would be nice to have a team like St. Louis, eventually; always in the conversation as an organization with a good plan, and the infrastructure and know-how to execute that plan. Until now, this has been completely foreign to us.

    Liked by 2 people

  15. I get what you are saying Holly. I think Avila was in way over his head but before I declare the new regime a success I want to see some results. Who says the change will help Torkelson until we see him actually hit? Same with moving Haase up – let’s see if his pitch framing improves. It is easy to buy into the talk. I hope the walk is as good.

    Liked by 2 people

Comments are closed.