HOPE.

(Part One)

By:  Holly Horning

Are you perusing the papers every day looking for updates on the Tigers? Good luck with that.

Even if you go to the major local papers, where any news at all should be located, there is “Nix! Zip! Diddly! Bupkis!” (Forgive me, I have to regularly include a quote from A Fish Called Wanda in my blogs.)

And there won’t be anything for awhile. (Imagine how hard it is for Kurt and me to write about this team every day. The beat writers are weenies compared to us.)

Chris Ilitch has said he’s “extremely pleased” with the progress. He’s extended Al Avila, who is doing a phenomenal job. So is the Front Office. The manager is still gainfully employed as are all of his/Jim Leyland’s/Brad Ausmus’ coaches because they are great at what they do and the stats prove it.

As for players, we’re not expecting anyone from AAA to make the jump until maybe late next year. Or, should we say, deserving to make the jump.

As well, we’re not expecting free agents of any significance to be signed. If any holes need to be filled, the Tigers will sign a journeyman or two. Maybe.

More than likely, they will sign guys who have been around and trying to get back to the bigs by accepting minor league contracts. Bargain basement shopping at its finest. Ron Gardenhire said as much in an interview a week ago. He commented “I’ve been told there’s very little money to spend on players for 2020.”

So there you have it. A team that finished with MLB’s worst record for 2019 with 114 losses and a .292 winning percentage is quite happy with how things are going. No need to fire anyone, hire anyone new or spend any money to help the team get better.

This either means that the world’s biggest idiots are running this organization or that MLB needs to start an investigation focused on the owner’s intent to be purposely non-competitive. There’s a phrase for this now – “tanking is banking.”

But, wait!

Don’t go near that ledge, readers. Just not yet.

What we’re seeing could actually be a good thing. A great thing even.

This frozen-in-time situation – this nonsensical lack of action – we’re seeing, most logically supports the strategy that the team is closer to being sold.

The drumbeats are getting louder, folks. And more frequent.

And people are talking. People who have connections to the team, like former Tigers.

I know I’ve been writing about this move for 2 years now with the first clues appearing. And like any big, expensive organization for sale, it takes time to make it happen. Pieces have to be put in place, the books need to be righted and the organization has to be stripped down and made as efficient as possible so it looks good to a potential new owner. Afterall, you want to get the maximum price when you sell.

So, the clues. I’ve got lots of them. Some big, some small. All logical. And all support each other.

And when you add them all up, there is a pattern. And you know how I feel about patterns if you’ve been reading Totally Tigers for awhile…

In fact, too many clues to write about all of them in one blog, so I am going to split this discussion into two parts. This means you have to promise to come back next Tuesday because I’ll be saving the best for last. And if you don’t, I’ll be coming for you…..


Let’s get on with it!

First of all, who is the buyer?

Dan Gilbert.

Everyone who is talking only mentions his name, no one else’s. And it’s also been said that his stroke put a kink in the timeline of the sale – but that it is still happening with some reports saying as soon as “this spring.”

Gilbert, as you may know, already owns one sports team – the Cleveland Cavaliers. And he’s from Detroit.

But did you know that he really wanted to buy a baseball team instead of basketball? Back in 2004, he tried to buy the Milwaukee Brewers. Now is just the perfect time to buy his hometown team. Baseball teams don’t come up for sale frequently.

Buying the Tigers would also enhance and complement his current downtown projects. Projects, btw, that are actually in progress, unlike Chris Ilitch’s District Detroit.

The biggest clue that there is a deal brewing is Gilbert’s continuing efforts to sell all of his casinos. As you know, MLB forbids ownership of them.

Dan’s casinos are reported by the financial media as being “hugely profitable.” If so, why would he want to sell? He’s given no reason at all despite the imminent signing of papers with the new owners.

Gilbert is selling the Greektown Casino for $1 billion. Conveniently, it is close to what the Tigers are asking for their team.

On the other hand, several financial papers are speculating that Ilitch Holdings is having some cash flow issues and needs to free up some greenbacks in order to pursue some non-baseball-related projects. Remember, most baseball owners don’t buy teams because they love baseball so much. They buy them for the investment – the very safe and very lucrative investment that they can later sell at a huge profit and use to inject into their other businesses.

It’s clear that Chris doesn’t have the connection with baseball that his dad had. If he did, we’d be seeing much more of him at Comerica. He’s absent from the owner’s suite and makes only 1-2 appearances each season for mandatory events. Heck, he didn’t even appear at the contract extension of his GM, Al Avila.

Chris’ real passion, however, is hockey. He has played since a kid and continues playing every weekend for the past 20 years in an adult league. He’s also grooming his kids to play the game. There are a number of national articles in which he gushes about the game.

And baseball? (Insert the sound of crickets here.)

“Nix! Zip! Diddly! Bupkis!”

You’re simply not going to keep a team that doesn’t interest you. You’ve got enough going on in life and other projects that require your time and attention.  You can’t spread yourself thin with too many businesses.  Your other businesses will suffer.

Meanwhile, at Comerica, a number of reports are coming out. Employees reporting that the team is in “budgetary lockdown.” That Ilitch is only focused on saving money, not on improving the team, from all of their interactions with ownership.

Articles have come out about employees being laid off and Comerica shops being closed. Especially this year. And it helps support the financials in which the Tigers drastically cut their operating expenses which used to be double the average in MLB. The organization made their first profit last year – even after 98 losses – after over a decade. It helps to make the books look good when you want to sell.

Several employees have reported that they are seeing a swarm of new, non-Comerica people in suits, digging around. Whether they are accountants hired to reduce costs or investigating on behalf of Gilbert is unknown. But the employees sense that something is happening.

To come full circle, it now makes sense that the Tigers aren’t making any personnel moves. They are keeping everyone, despite the 114 losses this year. They are not going out to hire anyone new and logically, that is because the team is going to be sold. It doesn’t make sense to spend the time and money to bring in new people who will most likely be gone in (maybe) months.

If you’re selling the team, you really don’t care about its progress anymore. You’ve moved on.

You simply care about the sale price now.

Next Tuesday, come back for Part Two in which the biggest clues will be revealed that point to the Tigers being sold. Until then, please limit your comments to those topics listed above only, saving your thoughts on other subjects for next week.


 Totally Tigers loves your comments!  But please remember that responses are only published if they address today’s topic, are respectful and do not exceed the maximum response length.  All rules are at:   https://totallytigers.wordpress.com/commentsrules/.

28 thoughts on “HOPE.

  1. Holly, everything you say makes sense. I post every Tigers story/ news link from media sites at a Detroit based message board, and the one constant I have noticed is how much the Detnews, Freep, and Mlive have virtually stopped with any Tigers news, the blogs and national baseball sites don’t have much to offer either. I hope you are right, our Tigers need new ownership, one that cares about improving the front office with vibrant forward thinking minds in analytics, minor league player development, and winning back the franchises loyal fan base.

    Liked by 6 people

    • My thoughts exactly. Although they finally won that single championship, the Cavs were eerily similar to the Tigers. They got 20% of a cast of characters in place with a generational talent just like the Tigers (Lebron; Miggy and JV) but were utterly inept at assembling a supporting cast.

      Liked by 2 people

    • I don’t understand the negative comments about Dan Gilbert. Would you rather have CI continue owning the team waiting for an owner you would approve of?

      Liked by 3 people

  2. Suppose you’re right about Dan Gilbert buying the Tigers next spring (you have this skeptic convinced now). How will that impact his ability to make changes for the 2020 season. (I don’t want to watch another bad season of Tiger baseball!)

    Liked by 2 people

    • MLB doesn’t adhere to traditional economics, Jim. With anti-trust protection at the government level and big market teams subsidizing losers they can bludgeon (like our Tigers), it’s an upside-down world. Amazing anyone can turn a profit on the garbage product we’ve been watching. But hey, where would the Harlem Globetrotters be without the Washington Generals?

      Liked by 4 people

  3. Hey Holly – I am daily amazed at the quality, ability to keep every article fresh and interesting. Your content is beyond belief. And how you two can find enough topics to fill the days, weeks and months.i am amazed and thank you. Without this blog I stopped fallowing the tigers or the commissioner ‘s juiced batting practice long ago.

    Liked by 9 people

  4. I sincerely hope you are right about the sale. You are certainly correct about an organization “frozen in time”. I also think Holly’s pat on her own back about the challenge producing a blog on this has colorless, do-nothing team is richly deserved.

    Liked by 6 people

    • I agree Hugh. Just last night as I was watching the game my mind wandered to TT and how much fun the back and forth commentaries have been lately. I also wondered how I, a retired guy, could possibly come up with something new virtually every day as they do. How Holly and Kurt manage to do it while also holding down jobs is beyond me. Thanks for keeping it going guys!!

      Liked by 7 people

    • Holly and Kurt keeping this blog going reminds me of Seinfeld, Hughie. They said it was a “show about nothing” but it was always fun to watch. Here, we get great writing and insightful comments based on a team that’s “got nothing.”

      Liked by 5 people

  5. Ok, Holly, I’m game. Suppose Gilbert does buy the Tigers. I hope he brooms the entire front office. If Jim Leyland remains with the organization as an “influence peddler” you can bet the farm and blog he’ll do his absolute best to talk up and promote Astros first base coach DON KELLY to be the next Tigers manager under a new owner. You know the old saying “the more things change the more they……..”

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Holly, you & Kirt continue to write intelligent, in depth and insightful columns and I thank you. In the midst of the hot stove league we get nothing from the local Detroit News & Free Press beat writers.. they are either too lazy or to repressed to produce news about our Tigers.

    Liked by 3 people

  7. Holly, you just made my day! It’s so hard to contain the smile on my face – and I’m sure I’ll have it every time I come back to read comments. THANK YOU for your continued excellence in researching and writing about the team that we love! I’m in agreement with others that the Totally Tigers blog that you and Kurt have created has been a salvation for readers like me.

    Liked by 3 people

  8. Holly..awesome,positive article! My hopes have risen for a new Tiger ownership that will enhance and care about our franchise. Looking forward to Tuesday! Thank you!!

    Liked by 2 people

  9. Well Holly I just talked to my baby brother and he said that indeed there has been a lot of talk about Dan Gilbert purchasing the Tigers and that it would be great but as far as definitively knowing that Dan Gilbert is, Johnny doesn’t know more than we do things are pretty secret about that lot of it depends on Dan Gilbert’s recovery from his stroke that is one thing Johnny told me
    Fr Paul Harvey here lol!!!

    Liked by 3 people

  10. Me the past 2 seasons = Red at the Start of Shawshank.
    Me after reading TT = Red at the End of Shawhank: “I find I’m so excited, I can barely sit still or hold a thought in my head. I think it’s the excitement only a free man can feel, a free man at the start of a long journey whose conclusion is uncertain. I hope I can make it across the border. I hope to see my friend and shake his hand. I hope the Pacific is as blue as it has been in my dreams. I hope.”

    Liked by 6 people

  11. All those incessant Detroit daily newspaper articles about how great the Single and Double-A prospects are might have been doing double duty– mollifying frustrated fans and pumping up buyer interest in farm system production. We’ll see if another multi-millionaire really loves baseball or not.

    Liked by 1 person

  12. Thanks Holly, some hope for the future. Look forward to Part 2. What CI did with the Wings shows he is not stupid, just that has little interest in the Tigers.

    Liked by 1 person

  13. Holly, I hope and pray you are right about a possible sale!! That would be like an early Christmas present and it makes me giddy just thinking about it. I have no idea how good Dan Gilbert would be as the owner, but I figure it absolutely cannot get any worse than Chris I and his band of dinosaurs!!!! Thanks for brightening my day:-)

    Liked by 5 people

Comments are closed.