By:  Kurt Snyder

Of all the news that’s been reported on during the last week, what is the most discouraging and worrisome development?

Just after the season ended last year, the Tigers had decisions to make on 2 players; Cameron Maybin and Francisco Rodriguez. At the time, the Tigers were kicking off what they thought was the beginning of their next mission. Get younger, get leaner.

In my mind, I understood the rationale of declining the option on one or the other, if not both. But, I couldn’t envision the Tigers keeping both given the new franchise edict.

So let me take you through a little exercise. All fans, all people for that matter, are quite familiar with it, and they practice it almost every day. It’s called hindsight. It’s much easier to make a decision in hindsight.

Hindsight is defined as the recognizing of the dangers and/or possibilities of a situation after it occurs.

If you knew then what you know now about both of these players, the decision may have been different. The departure of Cam Maybin saved the Tigers $9M but left a gaping hole in centerfield which they won’t clear up until almost the last day of spring.

KRod arrived to camp late, left almost immediately for the WBC, was injured while he was there and now has us more worried than ever. It was reported Tuesday that his already heat-challenged fastball that had topped out at about 89 mph all through last season has dipped considerably, ranging in the neighborhood of 86.

Sorry, but that’s just not enough differentiation between the speed of his ‘fastball’ and his wide array of 82-84 mph change-ups. I believe the man is in trouble.

I understood why he was the one the Tigers chose to hold on to; he gave them an experienced closer until they cut him loose for a prospect later in the season. But closing games just got a whole lot more difficult.

You see, the luxury of a dominant closer is that they can save games even when they make mistakes with their pitches. KRod had that when he was an Angel. He was able to blow batters away with fastballs and puzzle them with debilitating breaking pitches and change-ups.

But even as a Brewer and last season as a Tiger, he still had the ability to get batters out. He’s made mistakes that hurt him however, because he doesn’t have that dominant fastball. But he’s been able to use it effectively to set up his collection of change ups.

His problem to start this season though is he can’t effectively set up off-speed pitches with a weak fastball. Hitters are going to make him pay.

Obviously, the hope is that the fastball will improve. The worry is that it won’t. And if it doesn’t, there goes the production. There goes the closer. And there goes the value. The trade value. KRod, assuming he made it to the trade deadline, would bring the Tigers a prospect from a team looking to make a playoff push. It certainly was a key reason they chose to hold onto him.

You see, the Tigers made a choice. Sacrifice a centerfielder for a rookie replacement or sacrifice a closer for a rookie replacement. Maybin probably gets them little in return should they want to deal him during the season. Heck, they got very little for him before the season. In his absence, it appears Jacoby Jones gets first shot at centerfield. A great opportunity for a rookie.

If the Tigers would have traded KRod after last year, I believe they would have gotten a better prospect, given the receiving team was still getting a pitcher fresh off a 44 save season. But the Tigers got a little greedy, maybe thinking they could get even more for him at the trade deadline; IF he continued to produce and IF he stayed healthy.

They were asking a lot of him. But they may be going to the well one time too many; the numbers just don’t add up. So everybody hold their breath once again. It wouldn’t be baseball in Detroit if we weren’t nervous in the ninth.

But bad ninth innings right away in April may await us; and the Tigers may wish they kept their centerfielder instead.

In hindsight.

If you’re not yet on Twitter, you need to be!  It is so much more than 140 characters.  Totally Tigers presents the best articles, videos, pictures and radio/tv interviews for the most relevent news on the Tigers not found easily or locally.  We do all the work for you and bring you the latest news as it breaks.  And we’ll always leave you thinking.  Read us in the morning and get updates on the latest news throughout the day on Twitter.

      Tons of video on all the top Tigers

      In the batting cage with Nick(olas)

      More CF shopping rumors

      Good news on Bruce Rondon

      Jones imitating Kinsler

      Updates on all the news and injuries hours before the newspapers report it

      JV’s killer commercial

      What JV and Lolich have in common

      The New Kaline mural

      Bat flips have been replaced with ????

      McCann’s interview evaluating all the young pitching talent


  1. If he is finished, my question would be how soon will Ausmus/Avila recognize it? How quickly will they make the change? How many games will be lost in the meantime? “Frankie IS the closer”, afterall.


    • Totally agree. ‘THAT’ (how long they keep him in the role) is question 1B behind the 1A of “is he finished.” Although I don’t want to relive the Todd ‘Rollercoaster’ Jones years of closing, those were still preferable to the final months of Papa Valverde and/or recent history of inflexible bullpen roles (e.g., Joe Nathan & Joba).


  2. It won’t matter, even though the Tigers management continually stumble around and make poor personnel decisions, they will still be in contention this year due to the fact the Central Division is really BAD at this time.


    • The Tigers will be in contention to finish second in their division, which will likely place them far behind teams in other divisions vying for a wild card berth. The bullpen is still a mess, and the lineup – as we saw yesterday with all hands on deck except for JD – produced a whopping two runs. Yes, it’s only one game, but the offense is MIA far too often.


  3. The Tigers have repeatedly invested in “proven” closers, such as Nathan which almost always proves to be a sucker bet. And anybody could see that KRod was doing it with mirrors last year, that eventually MLB hitters would figure out how to lay off the change up in the dirt. I’m no Billy Beane, and I knew that Cameron Maybin was going to do a lot more to win games than KRod.


  4. Isn’t there a saying that hindsight may be 20/20 but foresight is always better? There seems to be a sequence of moves every season that end up creating problems not solving them. Apparently forethought isn’t a strong suit.


  5. History comment. A long time ago the tigers went outside the org. To hire a mngr. Most players wanted Campbell to promote thier AAA mgr. Sparky was the hire as Campbell passes on the one he felt was still too young to run a contender. Jimmy Leland had to wait a few years learning his trade. Looking back-campbell had it right. Brad’s day is far in the future.


Comments are closed.