By:  Holly Horning 

We all know that making it to October baseball requires the usual great pitching and hitting. But why do all the oddsmakers fail year after year to predict who will raise the flag at the end of the season? Why do teams look great on paper but somehow fail to perform up to expectations?

Baseball teams are a lot like recipes. It’s not enough to simply have the ingredients. You’ve also gotta know how much of each element you need as well as understand when to add them to the mix, in what order and how long to cook.

So what about the Tigers? What recipe do they need to follow in order to be highly competitive this year? Other than the usual “pitchers need to pitch well” and “hitters need to hit”, here are 10 issues that held them back last year and need to be addressed in 2016.


Remember the last time we had Tigers who weren’t limping around the bases? Me neither. The team needs a new approach to building and maintaining player health in order to prevent injuries. A proactive, not reactive, mindset as well as new trends need to be adopted.


Despite their higher team batting average, the Tigers scored a mere 29% of the runners they put on base and ranked 29th in base running last year. It’s not just the speed, it’s about the ability to correctly read balls put into play and how to read opposing players. It’s not enough for Brad to push for more running, he’s got to have a coach who can effect change.


Despite having MLB’s best team BA and the most hits in 2015, the Tigers ranked in the middle of the pack in getting runners in from scoring position. Some due to bad base running but also their failure to bunt, draw walks and hit sacrifice flies/beat the shift in order to advance runners. Can Wally Joyner shed his resume of working with teams who struggle to score runs? Which leads us to…….


The team ranked in the lower third of MLB in walks and also total pitches seen with JD Martinez as the best Tiger – but ranking far down the list. Working the count offers huge advantages to hitters the longer they can stay in the box while also wearing down opposing pitchers. Again, this is an issue unresolved by Tiger coaching for more than a couple of years.


All the excuses were used up last year – injuries, bad bullpen and a changing Front Office. Given how the Tigers had only 1 winning month (April) in 2015, Brad has to be on a short leash in 2016. Avila may have had ulterior motives for bringing him back but if the team doesn’t gel quickly this year, he’ll have to pull the trigger sooner than later.


Bruce Bochy does it. So does Joe Maddon. They both use their closer during the most high-leverage situation which may not be the 9th inning. How many times did we see Brad save his best pitcher for the last inning, only to be blown out of the game in the 7th or 8th? The best managers don’t employ cookie-cutter rules. Which brings us to….


There is a huge difference between playing to win and playing so as not to lose. Planning game strategy that is either too short- or long-sighted. Playing well against good teams or pitchers but dropping games against the weaker ones or mediocre pitchers. Many teams have a mental conditioning coach to enhance strategy development and consistency – and the Tigers should, too.


The Tigers did not have an innings-eater in 2015 with Alfredo Simon at 187 IP as the best on the team. Studies show that the more innings-eaters (200 IP) a team has, the more games they win and the better the chance they have of making the post-season. According to these analyses, the Tigers need to have 3 of their starters step up in 2016.


Some lead by example while others are vocal. Stars like Miggy need to focus on physical performance which is why it’s important to have extroverted players who can communicate often and well with their teammates. But Ian can’t do it alone. Let’s hope that James McCann and at least one other teammate can keep him from being too lonely in that job.


Some days we saw a team on fire but more often than not, we saw players who looked disinterested, bored and complacent. This falls directly on the manager who is responsible for motivating players and inspiring their best performances. Is it a coincidence that managers like Bochy, Maddon, and Francona develop teams that turn out to be consistently passionate and driven towards success?

Are there other weaknesses the Tigers need to address? Let us know! As the season goes on, we’ll come back to see if these issues of concern are being addressed.


  1. I’ve noticed a weakness among the fans in attendance. It can be mid summer,hot, sellout crowd and we are down by 1 in the 6th. The place is as quiet as a morgue. Does Comerica produce an atmosphere not conducive to raucous cheering that baseball really does take a back seat to everything else that’s going on inside the ballpark, er, entertainment complex?


  2. #5. Avila – ulterior motive with Brad? Cmon, your teasing. Putting a contingent of players (a few “stars” included) on notice to step it up in turn for their desire for retaining Ausmus? Other than saving the cost of lettering a new managers uniform, I can think of no others.


    • Hi, Jerry – As I’ve said before in our blog, you can’t fire someone unless you have a better option ready to go. Keeping Brad, for now, effectively shuts down the leaks and source coming from the Tigers organization, who is now deemed unreliable and powerless. It allows Al to establish and solidify power and after Dave’s release, it keeps the team from appearing unstable. Esp. important considering the need to attract new players. But the most important reason may be that the manager(s) they want, aren’t yet available. Why fire someone and hire someone else just for the sake of it? Hiring a new manager would require being locked into another 3+ year contract. A 3-year contract that would prevent them from hiring the manager they really want. Sometimes, the best move is the one you don’t make right away. And sometimes, the smart ones (in this case, Avila) don’t reveal their hand right away. Thanks for reading! – Holly


Comments are closed.